Amy Goldstein is JFS’s development director and pursued doctoral research in medieval Jewish cultural history. The day after Thanksgiving, she makes this soup for Shabbat dinner; she shares the story behind it in her own words below.
Thanksgiving has always been a major holiday for my family. My great-grandparents came to the United States around the turn of the 20th century from Eastern Europe and their daughter, grandma Ann, who hosted the holiday every year, was so proud of being an American Jew. She wanted everyone to understand the freedoms Jews enjoyed in this country.
Like many new immigrant Jewish women, her mother Mollie worked in a New York City shirtwaist factory and boarded with a family when she arrived in 1909. She moved to Detroit when she married my great-grandfather Solomon.
On Fridays when I was little, we drove 15 minutes to her apartment for a Shabbat feast that always started with a golden chicken soup made with necks, bones, and feet, reflecting her early childhood in Przemyśl, in the Galicia region of Austria (present-day Poland). When grandma Ann started hosting Thanksgiving, she added this traditional Jewish chicken soup to the otherwise classic American lineup of turkey, stuffing, and pies.
Love of soup has endured in our family, and my daughter Molly and I put our own twist on a Thanksgiving soup. We take the leftover turkey carcass and make a soup for Shabbat the next day, adding nutty wild rice and mushrooms, to make it taste like “Thanksgiving in a bowl.” The dish always reminds me of my great-grandmother Mollie and grandma Ann and those long-ago gatherings.
Cooking note: If you don't have a whole carcass, you can use a few wings, legs, thighs, and/or necks, instead (about 8 pounds total). Arrange the pieces in a single layer on a baking sheet and roast in a 400°F oven until golden brown and cooked through. Remove the meat from the bones and set aside, reserving the bones for the stock.